Last month I made my case for not buying new stocks at today’s market levels but not selling them either. My so-called third option was to redirect incremental dollars elsewhere. I ended last month’s post with three questions:
- Where am I getting new dollars from?
- Where are my incremental dollars going?
- How am I generating a return on them?

Let me take the questions one at a time.
Where am I getting new dollars from?
From two places. First, dividends. My portfolio continues to generate substantial quarterly dividends. Nearly all of my top twenty positions pay one, with four notable exceptions: Amazon, Tesla, Berkshire Hathaway, and Intuitive Surgical.
Second, trimming. I trim my positions a little whenever the market makes a new high. I reported some of the recent trims here and here.
Raising cash is how I dial down my market risk. The last time I raised cash was in May, when I reported that cash made up 17.8% of my portfolio, counting both my dry powder and my rainy-day funds. Four months later the market is at about the same level, and my cash is at about 18%.
Looking back ten years, my cash has grown faster than the portfolio itself:

My portfolio tripled over those ten years, while my cash grew more than fivefold. As my net worth rose, I regularly trimmed stocks so that cash would grow faster than the portfolio.
Where are my incremental dollars going?
Some goes to household spending, but most of it goes into my dry powder cash hoard.
I’ve written about my dry powder strategy many times in this space (for instance, see here and here). Suffice it to say that I consider it an important part of my portfolio and a tool for controlling how much market risk I take. Apart from money set aside for spending, I keep this cash mostly in tax-advantaged accounts.
How am I generating a return on it?
I could simply keep my cash in 3-month T-bills or a money market fund. Instead, since 2017 I’ve invested it in protective collars on stocks I already follow: I buy a stock in 100-share lots and, for each lot, buy a put below the current price and sell a call above it.
In up markets, when I don’t need this cash, the collars share in the gains up to the call strike and usually beat T-bills. In down markets, the put puts a floor under my money. I don’t earn much then, but that’s when I’m spending this cash on stocks anyway.
Each collar runs two years or more, so how do I get at the cash when a dip comes? With a ladder. Because I keep opening new collars over time, some are always close to expiring, and those can usually be closed at or near breakeven. Closing a collar long before expiry can cost a little, and long-dated options don’t always trade heavily, so the ladder is what keeps this cash accessible.
I don’t expect these collars to beat interest rates by a wide margin. Even though I’m making hedged stock bets, the market is efficient, and principal protection costs money. That’s one reason I never hedge my much larger stock portfolio. So when stocks fall, I don’t expect much profit. When they rise, my collars participate to some extent and generally beat bonds and money markets.
How have they done?
Since 2017, I’ve seen all kinds of markets: the short, sharp Covid panic in 2020, a full-year bear market in 2022, and milder drops of just under 20% in late 2018 and the 2025 tariff shock. Here’s how my 145 closed collars fared, grouped by the year I opened them:

* The 2024 and 2025 rows include only collars already closed; those were mostly early winners. The laggards from those years are still open, so final returns could come down a bit.
How I calculated these: my collar returns are annualized IRRs from actual cash flows, including dividends, over the exact dates each collar was open. For the T-bill column, I applied daily 3-month T-bill rates to those same cash flows.
Most of my collars were set up for two years or more, but I closed about 70% of them early, usually after the stock had run well past the call strike.
A few takeaways:
- The floor costs something. The minimum return I locked in when opening a collar was below T-bill rates every year, and slightly negative on average. The upside in good years more than made up for it.
- 2021 was where principal protection earned its keep. I opened those collars at near-zero interest rates, right before the 2022 bear market, and many ended at their floors. As a group they broke even. That’s not a loss. That trailed T-bills, but the stocks underneath fell much further.
- Overall, my collars returned 4.44% a year, compared with 2.83% for T-bills, about 1.6 points a year more. That works out to about 55% more profit than T-bills would have earned on the same cash.
Cash-Plus Collars
I first explained this collar structure in a 2018 post. In the same post I also described a “buffered collar” with an extra short put, which I no longer use because it offers only limited downside protection. I explained why in a later 2018 post.
Here’s another way to think about each protective collar. It’s equivalent to:
- A Treasury bond that pays the put strike at expiry, plus the dividends, and
- A bet on the stock’s rise between the put and call strikes, technically a call spread.
So each collar locks in a risk-free rate, spends part of that interest on stock upside, and collects whatever that upside pays. It’s essentially a do-it-yourself principal-protected note (read my 2019 note on defined outcome investing), on stocks I pick, with no bank fees. It also explains my edge over cash: it’s a slice of the stock market’s return, delivered with a floor. It’s not a free lunch.
One could argue that the extra 1.6% annual return isn’t worth the effort of setting up these collars and managing them for years. That’s fair criticism, and for most individual investors a money market fund or Treasuries is the simpler choice. I enjoy the challenge of beating cash rates, though. The stocks I write collars on are ones I already research, and collars give me something productive to do when, as in today’s market, I’m not buying or selling much else.
What I hold today
I’ll keep investing my cash this way. In a June 2020 post I shared a snapshot of my collars at the time. Here’s what I hold today:

If held to expiry, these open collars would return between 0.83% a year (if every stock ends at or below its put strike) and 7.47% a year (if every stock ends above its call strike). At today’s prices they’re on track for about 4.4%. If stocks do well over the next year or two, I expect to lock in 7%-plus. In a downturn I won’t gain much, but I won’t lose my principal either.
Leave a Reply